We didn’t lose religion. We moved it into politics.
For most of human history, religion wasn’t one part of life among others. It was the frame that held everything together. It told people where they came from and where they were going, what was sacred and what was forbidden, who belonged and who didn’t. It gave them rituals for birth, marriage and death, a community that knew their names, and a story large enough to make sense of their suffering. Whether you believed every word or not, you lived inside it.
The hunger that religion once held for us never went anywhere. We still need to feel that we stand on the side of good. We still need to belong to a people, to believe our suffering means something, to know where evil lives so we can keep it at a safe distance. When the churches emptied, those needs didn’t empty with them. They went looking for a new home, and many of them found it in our political identities.
None of us is above this. And if part of our political life has become a kind of faith, it’s worth looking at what it inherited from the old one. Every faith that tells us what is good must also tell us where evil comes from. For centuries, in the Christian world, that answer was the devil.
It’s easy to smile at him today, with his horns and his pitchfork, as if he belonged to a more naive age. But a figure doesn’t survive for two thousand years because people are naive. It survives because it answers something real in us. The devil gave evil an address outside of us. If cruelty, envy or violence broke into the world, it came from him, not from the ordinary hearts of ordinary people. He gave a community something to stand against together, and few things bind people more tightly than a shared enemy. And he made a frightening world readable. There was light and there was darkness, and you could know which side you belonged to.
The need he answered is older than the devil himself. In the book of Leviticus, on the Day of Atonement, the priest laid his hands on a goat, confessed over it the sins of the whole people, and sent it out into the wilderness. The sins left with the goat, and our word “scapegoat” still carries that memory. Centuries later, the French thinker René Girard saw in this one of the oldest mechanisms that hold human groups together. When tension grows, a community finds someone to carry the blame, unites against them, and feels clean again.
There’s something in that ritual we tend to overlook, and it makes the ancients look more honest than we are. Everyone knew the goat was innocent. No one believed the animal had committed the sins of the people. It was a conscious act, a symbolic transfer the whole community performed with open eyes. We do the same thing today, but we no longer know we’re doing it. We load our fear and our guilt onto the other side, and we call it justice.
Christianity, whose founder asked his followers to love their enemies, became remarkably good at producing them. Across Europe, people accused of serving Satan were tried and burned as witches. Martin Luther denounced the Catholic Church, the Jews and even the Protestants who disagreed with him as agents of the devil. And when Europeans reached the Americas, the sacred practices of entire peoples were branded as devil worship, and that label became a license to burn their temples, persecute their healers and take their land. None of it required monsters. It only required ordinary people who were certain that evil lived somewhere else.
If that were the whole story, religion would have been little more than an efficient way of producing enemies. But alongside the devil, the same traditions kept another idea alive, one that pointed in the opposite direction: that evil doesn’t live only out there, but passes through every human heart, including your own. It survived in the teaching about removing the plank from your own eye before reaching for the speck in your neighbor’s. In confession and the examination of conscience. In the mystics, for whom the decisive battle was always fought within, against pride, fear and the need to be right.
That idea was ignored far more often than it was practiced, and often betrayed by the very institutions that preached it. The historian Elaine Pagels, in The Origin of Satan, traces how early Christians gradually turned the figure of Satan against their own opponents: first other Jews, then pagans, then fellow Christians who believed differently. What stays with me in her work is who those enemies were. Not distant strangers, but neighbors and rivals, people who looked almost exactly like them. The devil was rarely the one far away. More often, he was the one closest.
And yet, as Pagels also reminds us, there were always people like Saint Francis and Martin Luther King Jr., who stood firmly for what they believed was right without turning their opponents into devils. They show that the idea was never empty. Even when most people ignored it, the language was there for anyone willing to use it.
That language is part of what we lost when the old frame began to break. Many of us walked away from it, and often for good reasons: dogma, hypocrisy, the abuse of power. But the hunger it had held didn’t walk away with us, and politics was ready to receive it.
What is this hunger, exactly? Most of us never look at it directly, because it lives beneath our opinions. Underneath every belief we defend there is something more primitive: the need to feel safe in a world that is fundamentally uncertain. Life is chaotic. Things fall apart without warning. We lose people, work, health, the ground we thought we were standing on. Facing that chaos with open eyes is frightening, so the psyche reaches for a story that puts it in order. A story in which suffering has a cause, we belong to the good, and evil has a clear location.
And there is a second need, one we admit even less. We don’t want to carry our own darkness. The envy, the rage, the wish to dominate, the cruelty each of us is capable of on a bad day are heavy things to hold. It is a relief to find somewhere else to put them. For centuries, religion offered that place. Today, politics often does. The devil was never only a belief. He was a container for everything we couldn’t bear to see in ourselves.
Politics could offer almost everything the old faith had offered: a story of salvation, a community of believers, a cause worth sacrificing for, and a clear answer to the question of evil. What it doesn’t carry is that other idea, the one that points back at us.
Most political identities rest on the opposite premise: that evil lives on the other side. Very little in a political tribe asks you to look at your own shadow before naming someone else’s. It gives you the certainty of the believer without even the language that once reminded believers to doubt themselves. And this new faith has found a pulpit that never closes. Researchers from Cambridge and New York University analyzed nearly three million posts from American politicians and news outlets. Each additional word referring to the opposing side raised the odds of a post being shared by about 67 percent, and it worked the same way on the left and on the right. Every day, the feed preaches the same short sermon: look over there, that’s where the darkness is.
For many people, this has become the closest thing to a religious experience they have left. They don’t pray, they don’t meditate, they kneel before nothing. But in the heat of outrage they feel part of something larger than themselves: a communion with others who see what they see, a sense of purpose, the clean fire of being on the side of good. That’s why it is so hard to let go of an enemy. You’re not asking someone to change an opinion. You’re asking them to give up the only spiritual life they have.
History carries a hard lesson about what happens next. Sooner or later, those who hunt devils start to resemble what they hunt. The people who burned witches believed they were fighting evil. The inquisitors believed they were saving souls. Certainty without self-examination rarely produces saints; more often it produces cruelty that feels like virtue.
We live a quieter version of this every day, and most of us know it from the inside. The contempt we feel for the other side can feel righteous, even clean, yet it is often the very thing we condemn in them, pointed in the opposite direction. In the spiritual world, I’ve watched many people use their practice to feel good about themselves without ever doing the work underneath. Outrage serves exactly the same purpose. A few moments of righteous anger and we feel awake and on the right side of history, while nothing inside us has moved.
My own path has given me a different way of meeting darkness. Over years of studying and practicing shamanism, I’ve come to see the forces we call dark, rage, envy, fear, the hunger for power, not as devils waiting to be cast out but as forces of nature that move through every one of us. The work is not to eliminate them, and certainly not to load them onto someone else. It is to recognize them, to face them, and to learn what they have to teach before they quietly take control.
When you meet darkness this way, you become less afraid of it, and you no longer need someone else to carry it for you. Your enemy starts to look like what he always was: a human being caught in the same forces you are, sometimes more lost in them, sometimes less, but never a different kind of creature. This isn’t a soft position. Hatred asks nothing of us. Recognizing our own darkness in the person we oppose asks for everything.
Perhaps, then, the most radical thing any of us can do is to take that old idea seriously again, and turn it on ourselves. Not instead of caring about the world, but before acting in it. The next time you feel that familiar rush of outrage, pause long enough to ask a few honest questions. Who is your devil right now? What do you place on him that also lives in you, the intolerance, the arrogance, the fear, the need to be right? Is there a pleasure in condemning him, and if so, what is that pleasure protecting? And what might the other side be seeing that you have been refusing to look at?
You don’t need to share the answers with anyone. Just notice what happens in your body as you let the questions in.
None of this means that everything is relative. There is real harm in the world, and some ideas and actions deserve to be opposed with everything we have. But fighting an idea or an attitude is not the same as demonizing people. You can oppose what someone believes or does without vilifying the whole person, or the whole group they belong to. When we need a devil, our enemy quietly becomes part of the foundation of who we are, and we end up defending him almost as fiercely as we attack him, because without him we would no longer know where we stand.
The people who moved history toward greater justice rarely needed devils. They saw what was wrong with great clarity and fought it with everything they had, and still they refused to surrender the humanity of the people on the other side. That refusal wasn’t weakness. It was the source of their clarity.
There is one more devil I want to tell you about, because his story turns this whole question inside out. In the Yoruba religion of West Africa, and in the Afro-Brazilian traditions of Candomblé and Umbanda that grew from it, there is a figure called Exu, or Èṣù. He is the guardian of the crossroads, of doorways and markets. He is the messenger who carries words and offerings between people and the divine. He is neither simply good nor simply evil. His task is to make passage possible, and that’s why, in many ceremonies, he is honored first: without him, no message gets through.
In the nineteenth century, when the Bible was translated into Yoruba, the translator needed a word for Satan. He chose Èṣù. The translator was Samuel Ajayi Crowther, a man rescued from slavery who became the first African bishop of the Anglican Church. With one word, the guardian of communication became the enemy of God, and generations of believers learned to fear the very figure their ancestors had trusted to carry their prayers. In Nigeria today, there is still a campaign to undo that translation.
Exu’s story is worth remembering every time we turn someone into a devil. When we demonize a person, a group or half a country, we don’t only misjudge them. We close the crossroads. We shut the one door through which something new could reach us: the conversation we refuse to have, the question we won’t hear, the part of ourselves we can only meet in the face of the person we oppose. So the next time you meet your devil, try asking what Exu would ask. What message is trying to get through here, and what door am I keeping shut?
There’s a reason Exu fits so badly into our categories. He is neither saint nor demon, and that is exactly what our devils make us forget: no one is entirely good, and no one is entirely evil. The worst atrocities in history were rarely committed by people who believed they were doing evil. They were committed by people who were certain they were doing good. The witch hunters, the inquisitors, the purifiers of every age slept well at night. What protects us is not finding the right side. It’s keeping enough nuance in our perspective to doubt our own.
So I’ll leave you with a question only you can answer: who would you be without your devil?
Maybe the devil was never the enemy at the gate. Maybe he was the gate.
Sources
- Rathje, Van Bavel and van der Linden, “Out-group animosity drives engagement on social media,” PNAS, 2021; summary from the University of Cambridge.
- Elaine Pagels, The Origin of Satan: How Christians Demonized Jews, Pagans, and Heretics (1995); see the Christian Science Monitor review.
- Leviticus 16, the Day of Atonement and the scapegoat ritual.
- René Girard, on the scapegoat mechanism.
- Global Voices, “Esu is not satan: A Yoruba campaign against religious discrimination,” 2025.